I >loveheart< gadgets: Accessibility

The root argument posed by this weeks BCM112 lecture, was the ideological battle between open-ended, rough-and-tumble ‘generative platforms’ (i.e Android), and their conservative, constricting, law-abiding, prim-and-proper neighbor: ‘locked devices’ (i.e iOS). So, I thought I’d better delve into this dynamic. While just an example, those two competing technological platforms show that in this day and age, the open platform will always prevail. Not dissimilar to Dennaton’s approach to distribution as I touched on earlier, but I feel there’s another great, timely example to demonstrate this ideological conflict: The war between legacy media and the internet’s advent of easy piracy.  Inspired by the debut of Netflix, what I view as a middle ground, I’d like to expand on this topic of legacy media outstaying its welcome and closed systems feeling the hurt that we explored in this week’s BCM112 lecture.

Selfie with me and my new best friend <3

Selfie with me and my new best friend ❤

FOXTEL CEO Richard Freudenstein stated, I’m assuming in an knowing, self-depreciating manner, that Netflix is “just here to make money” and have “no cultural investment in Australia.” While Foxtels prices have been cut in the lead up to the launch of Netflix, it’s still a minimum of $25 p/month with mandatory 12 month for a basic subscription subscription which does not include popular channels that screen Game of Thrones nor The Walking Dead, essentially the reason a lot of people turn to Foxtel. This is contrasted to Netflix’s minimum $9 month subscription with no cancellation fees and the ability to watch on multiple devices, in HD, with whatever show or movie in the burgeoning catalog tickles your fancy at that point in time. I like to think of Netflix as the middleground between pay TV and piracy; it’s the legal and convenient way to watch, whilst being affordable, and yet with still a limited catalog, not from a lack of Netflix’s trying. Telstra and News Corp. both own a 50% share in Foxtel and as explored in BCM110, they’re both conglomerates clinging to their outdated mediums, be it copper wiring or television respectively, and effectively stranglehold the rights to many popular shows. The morally ambiguous, ‘open’ alternative is of course streaming/torrenting or otherwise downloading these copyrighted shows via illegal means. This option provides free, high quality, and boundless options in viewing media that Foxtel, and Foxtel alone, more than likely has the legal right to be broadcasting. Naturally, this presents an issue for Foxtel, the lovechild of the two biggest and most influential media and broadcasting companies in Australia, who has to combat this convenient alternative to their overpriced and advertisement bloated service in some way, shape or form. Perhaps some kind of privacy demolishing, lavishly expensive, thinly veiled as ‘security’ measure, hilariously ineffective, Orwellian law would help keep those pesky pirates from straying from their service? Until then, middle-ground Netflix it is!



  1. abbide · March 27, 2015

    Nice example! I really struggled to think of a good quality example outside of the classic iOS vs android but you did an awesome job of mapping it out. I definitely think netflix is a good middle ground, because at home we have foxtel but now that I’m at uni I had to do a complete 360 and now I’m an avid streamer/downloader because there was never any other option/middle ground. I love that netflix is so reasonably priced but it is still a bit unfortunate that they don’t include some of the biggest TV shows.


    • Clancy Carr · March 27, 2015

      Thank for the comment 🙂 Yes well fortunately I don’t find myself addicted to GoT/TWD/any other show that I can’t go my week without watching, haha! That said, there’s really no other option than streaming to watch the shows I would like to without needing to sign up to Foxtel’s ludicrously expensive and comparatively unintuitive service. Guess I’ll just have to wait till Netflix gets the rights or physical box sets come out.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s